|
发信人: Wilczek (水木坑王), 信区: DP.THU 标 题: PRL两个负面意见被DAE推翻－血和泪的教训 发信站: 水木社区 (Wed Sep 9 04:05:42 2015), 站内 一个完整的文章，但含有comment某PRL文章的内容。去年12月投稿，翻了一个重要的错误：suggest了太多potential referees（10个左右），排除了两个被comment的文章的作者。最近开会跟一个PRL Editor聊天才知道一个潜规则，很可能这种情况下Editor把文章送给排除的两个敌人审稿了，结果也可想而知。忽然明白为啥以前每次都被拒的那么干脆直接了。。。所以，千万不要suggest审稿人，只排除潜在敌人即可！中间还经历了一次转PRA Rapid被PRA Editor拒绝，然后再转回PRL的惊险过程。 第一轮意见出来后，花了小半年时间用一种不同的方法计算了一下，发现定量上差别也不大，所以就重投。第二轮审稿意见回来后，发现根本就是模版化的拒稿意见，我就强烈感觉掉进陷阱了：两个审稿人很可能是排除的那两个人。所以在appeal的时候委婉的提到了这一点。最近发现DAE的report回来了，editor在重新找人审稿，说明我的猜测是对的：如果审稿人的选择没有原则上的问题（比如有利益冲突等），一般DAE是不可能推翻以前的审稿意见的。不幸的是，今天重新找的两个人都不愿意审。估计要拖到明年去了。。。 Opened Closed Description 08Sep15 08Sep15 Review request to referee; message received (not a report) 08Sep15 08Sep15 Review request to referee; message received (not a report) 05Aug15 26Aug15 Sent on appeal; report received 29Jul15 31Jul15 Ed. decision and/or ref. comments to author; response rcvd 08Jul15 27Jul15 Review request to referee; report received 22Jul15 Reminder to referee [others sent (not shown) at 1-2 week intervals] 08Jul15 17Jul15 Review request to referee; report received 08Jul15 Correspondence (miscellaneous) sent to author 08Jul15 Right to publish signature received 06Jul15 Correspondence (miscellaneous) sent to author 20May15 06Jul15 Correspondence sent to author; response received 03Jun15 Acknowledgment sent to author 03Jun15 Transferred from Phys. Rev. A to Phys. Rev. Lett. 29May15 Communication (miscellaneous) received from author 28May15 Correspondence (miscellaneous) sent to author 18May15 Acknowledgment sent to author 18May15 Correspondence (miscellaneous) sent to author 18May15 Transferred from Phys. Rev. Lett. to Phys. Rev. A 07Jan15 18May15 Ed. decision and/or ref. comments to author; response rcvd 10Dec14 07Jan15 Review request to referee; report received 10Dec14 30Dec14 Review request to referee; report received 24Dec14 29Dec14 Reminder to referee; response received 24Dec14 Reminder to referee [others sent (not shown) at 1-2 week intervals] 10Dec14 Correspondence (miscellaneous) sent to author 08Dec14 Acknowledgment sent to author 08Dec14 Correspondence (miscellaneous) sent to author -- ※ 来源:・水木社区 http://www.newsmth.net・[FROM: 204.121.138.*]
|